Who runs this site: Shady Reviews Calgary compiles reported bought reviews and review pressure in Calgary’s window and door industry from public sources. How we handle that.

Shady Reviews CalgaryWindows & doors, made for every Calgary home

Be cautious with these Calgary Window & Doors companies.

Five stars don’t prove a window company is good.

Not every Calgary window and doors company is doing white marketing. Some of them are caught in weird engagement, like buying reviews, ignoring negative sentiment, or lying in their statements. So be cautious with these on our list, and check the evidence behind each one before you trust the stars.

Illustration only. This is not a real review.

Alex M.

Profile hidden

★★★★★ 2 days ago

Amazing team! The sales rep was so friendly and the price was great. Highly recommend this company for all your needs!!!

  1. The reviewer’s profile is locked, so you can’t see what else they have reviewed.
  2. Praise covers the sales call only. Nothing about measuring, installation or service afterwards.
  3. Generic wording that could fit any business, and similar sentences show up on other profiles.
  4. It arrived in a burst: many reviews in a few days after months of silence.

Case files at a glance

The three window and door companies profiled below, with the strength of the evidence for each. Reports are not findings unless the level says a court or regulator has ruled.

Window and door companies profiled on Shady Reviews Calgary, with evidence level and company response.
Company Location Topic Evidence level What the record shows Company response
Ecoline Windows and Doors Branches in Alberta, British Columbia, Manitoba and elsewhere Customer complaints and reported pressure over reviews Level C Customer-reported Complaints on BBB and review sites. Claims that money was offered over negative reviews are unconfirmed. Disputes the complaints, says it delivered the contracted work, and says some negative reviews come from competitors.
Total Home Windows & Doors Vaughan, Ontario Suspected bought Google reviews Level B Researcher and press An independent researcher and the Toronto Star link the company to a network of suspicious Google profiles. No court or regulator has ruled. Says it never instructed, authorized or knowingly engaged anyone to post bought reviews.
Canadian Thermo Windows (Magic Windows) Woodbridge, Ontario Lawsuit over customers’ reviews Level A Court decision A 2021 court ruling found the lawsuit was meant to pressure customers into removing reviews, and ordered the company to pay $166,687. Its lawyers say the customers’ statements were untrue.

Case files: three window and door companies

Each file separates what has been reported from what the company says and from what has not been established. A report is not a finding, and every company here is invited to respond.

Level A

Court or regulator

A court ruling or a regulator’s finding.

Level B

Researcher and press

Named by an independent researcher and reported by news media. The company disputes it, and no court or regulator has ruled.

Level C

Customer-reported

Claims made by customers on review sites or forums. Nobody independent has confirmed them.

Level C: customer-reported

Ecoline Windows and Doors

Branches in Alberta, British Columbia, Manitoba and elsewhere. Reviews and complaints from customers in several provinces.

Customers report installation problems and warranty disputes, and a few say they were offered money or pressured over negative reviews. No court, regulator or news investigation has confirmed the review-related claims.

What has been reported

  • BBB complaint pages for branches in Ottawa, Calgary, Halifax, Edmonton and Winnipeg describe installation quality, measurement errors and disagreements over contract terms.
  • On TrustedPros, a Vancouver-area customer says a project coordinator offered a $50 gift card in connection with a negative review. This is one customer’s claim.
  • A Reddit thread, started by a customer looking for others with unresolved problems, says some customers were offered money to take reviews down and that a lawyer’s letter tied warranty coverage to removing reviews. The posts are anonymous and we have not seen documents.
  • Several commenters in that thread say the company wanted full payment before installation, and some Calgary customers say the warranty they were sold differs from the terms they later received.

What the company says

What is not established

  • We found no evidence that Ecoline posts or buys bought reviews.
  • Claims of payments or pressure to remove reviews come from individuals and are unconfirmed.
  • Different pages on Ecoline’s site give different founding years and installation totals. This may simply be outdated pages and is not evidence of wrongdoing.
  • Ratings differ widely between platforms and branches, so a single score says little.

What customers say

Summaries in our words of reviews and complaints posted on BBB. Names, staff names and identifying details are removed. We show praise and criticism side by side, and we have not verified any of it.

BBB Calgary profile: customer reviews average 4.72 out of 5 from 118 reviews, and BBB lists 29 complaints in the last three years, 4 of them in the last 12 months. Ecoline Calgary is BBB-accredited with an A+ rating.

Customer reviews

Windows replaced. The project manager explained the options clearly and followed up after the job. The installers kept the house clean and finished ahead of schedule.

BBB review, Calgary, March 2026, 5 of 5. Ecoline replied with thanks. Source: BBB Calgary reviews.

The customer spent more than a year deciding, and chose Ecoline partly because they did not feel pressured. Seven windows and a large patio door were done in one day, and the customer says the house is warmer so far. The price was a little below competitors, and the glass-breakage warranty was a deciding factor.

BBB review, Calgary, March 2026, 5 of 5. Ecoline replied with thanks. Source: BBB Calgary reviews.

After a break-in, the company measured and quoted a replacement door the next day. The door was made on time and installed as promised.

BBB review, Calgary, March 2026, 5 of 5. Ecoline replied with thanks. Source: BBB Calgary reviews.

A new front door was installed in one visit and the customer calls the work well done.

BBB review, Calgary, June 2026, 5 of 5. Source: BBB Calgary reviews.

Complaints, with Ecoline’s response

A customer says new custom exterior doors have several defects, including gaps, missing screws, trim separating and a sill coming loose, and that existing alarm wiring was covered over during installation. Ecoline and a retail partner offered a refund if the customer kept the door and signed a release. The customer says the release had confidentiality terms and declined.

Ecoline says the offer was more than fair and is final.

BBB complaint, Calgary, September 2026, status: answered. Source: BBB Calgary complaints.

Three windows were made too short more than once, and a scheduled installation fell through, so the project took about four months.

Ecoline apologized and completed the installation. The customer then confirmed the response was satisfactory.

BBB complaint, Calgary, September 2026, status: resolved. Source: BBB Calgary complaints.

Water came through a window several years after installation. The customer says independent companies told them the siding should have been peeled back so the window could be flashed properly.

Ecoline says the contract specified a brick-mould installation, its inspection found the seal intact, and the warranty does not cover siding or roof problems. The two sides disagree about whether the building code applies.

BBB complaint, Calgary, September 2026, status: answered. Source: BBB Calgary complaints.

After installation, a customer reported air coming in through the window drain holes, along with several finishing problems.

Ecoline agreed to replace one window as a test case. The customer says the wider issue is not yet resolved.

BBB complaint, Calgary, May to June 2026, status: answered. Source: BBB Calgary complaints.

A customer says the replacement patio door opens narrower than they believe local code allows.

Ecoline says the door matched the signed contract, and that custom products are non-refundable.

BBB complaint, Calgary, February 2025, status: answered. Source: BBB Calgary complaints.

On Google, the company does not respond to negative experiences from its clients

Critical Google reviews of Ecoline shown below. On each one, the company left no public reply, unlike the praise it responds to with thanks. Summaries are the reviewers’ own public posts; screenshots were captured from Google.

Google review by Sofi Katzenelson, 1 star: remote-control blinds broke within a year under warranty and Ecoline refused to replace them. No company response.
No company response
1★ — blinds failed under warranty, replacement refused. Reviewer: Local Guide, 59 reviews. View on Google Maps.
Google review by Lisa Rouleau, 1 star: says her quote was edited to remove her concerns and she would not use the company. No company response.
No company response
1★ — reviewer says her quote was edited to remove her concerns. Reviewer: 9 reviews. View on Google Maps.
Google review by Mike Stickland, 1 star: damage to entry paneling was not disclosed until after signing off on the work. No company response.
No company response
1★ — damage to entry paneling not disclosed until after the review was signed. Reviewer: 10 reviews. View on Google Maps.
Google review by Janice Wu, 1 star: replacement bathroom window sill is bowed with a gap in the corner, suggesting the window was forced into an improperly prepared opening. No company response.
No company response
1★ — replacement window sill bowed, gap in the corner; reviewer says the window was forced into a poorly prepared opening. Reviewer: 6 reviews, 12 photos. View on Google Maps.
Google review by Roy Vogelsang, 1 star: windows and doors installed by Eco-line in May and June 2023; says the window installation went well but the door work had problems, with photos of cracked and separating trim. No company response.
No company response
1★ — windows installed well but the door work is faulty; photos show cracked and separating trim. Reviewer: Local Guide, 10 reviews, 30 photos. View on Google Maps.
Google review by Ocko Ocko, 1 star: after more than 11 months to get a door, says Ecoline made an unsolicited offer to remove the review in exchange for refunding an accounting error of about 227 dollars, roughly 10 percent of the bill. Photos show a damaged door latch plate. No company response.
No company response
1★ — reviewer says that after an 11-month ordeal, the company offered to refund a billing error (about $227, ~10% of the bill) in exchange for removing the review. Reviewer: 6 reviews, 8 photos. View on Google Maps.
Google review by Jakub Drag, 1 star: spent over 30,000 dollars about 2.5 years ago to replace all windows and doors; says the vertical-slider windows are warped, will not lock and are bowing. Photos show a bowed window and a lock that will not align. No company response.
No company response
1★ — says $30k+ of replacement windows are warped, won't lock and are bowing about 2.5 years after installation. Reviewer: Local Guide, 15 reviews, 3 photos. View on Google Maps
Google review by Mark Imach, 1 star: used Ecoline Windows to replace a front door and several additional windows; calls it the worst experience he has ever had with a company on any contract work. No company response.
No company response
1★ — calls replacing a front door and several windows "the absolute worst experience" he has had with any contractor. Reviewer: 4 reviews, 7 photos. View on Google Maps
Google review by Claudia X, 1 star, edited 2 years ago: an update to an earlier post about her Ecoline experience; says windows were installed in June 2023, one window piece bent and separated from the glass, and that west-facing windows smell of burnt plastic in the sun. She also describes a man who came to her door claiming she was about to sign a deal with Ecoline. No company response.
No company response
1★ — an updated post about windows installed in June 2023; describes a window piece that bent and separated from the glass, and west-facing windows that smell of burnt plastic in the sun. Reviewer: Local Guide, 12 reviews, 8 photos. View on Google Maps
Google review by Linda McNaull, 1 star, a year ago: had 4 bedroom windows and 1 patio door completed by Ecoline after being told there was no glass issue. Photos show gaps and cracked sealant around window and door frames. No company response.
No company response
1★ — 4 bedroom windows and a patio door installed by Ecoline; photos show gaps and cracked sealant at the frames. Reviewer: Local Guide, 15 reviews, 12 photos. View on Google Maps

Company snapshot

Locations
Calgary AB, Port Coquitlam BC (Vancouver area), Winnipeg MB, and others
Founded
Company pages say 2002 and September 2008
Ratings
BBB Calgary: 4.72 from 118 reviews, 29 complaints in three years, A+ and accredited. TrustedPros: Vancouver 4.3 (31 reviews), Saskatoon 4.6 (40 reviews). HomeStars Calgary profile: 1,218 reviews. Company-published Google rating: 4.8, Winnipeg.
Checked
Ratings change, so check the platforms directly.

Level B: researcher and press

Total Home Windows & Doors

Vaughan, Ontario. Serves Toronto and the GTA.

An independent researcher says a network of Google profiles has been posting reviews for this company, and the Toronto Star names it. The company denies buying or authorizing bought reviews. No court or regulator has ruled.

What has been reported

  • An independent researcher, Kay Dean, a former federal investigator, says it found a network of profiles posting reviews for the company, with patterns it considers inorganic: frequent profile-name changes, locked profiles and photos taken from elsewhere online.
  • CTV News Toronto (July 2026) reported on celebrity-name reviews for a Toronto window business. CTV did not name the business. The researcher says its research on Total Home was the basis for that report.
  • Google told CTV it removed bought reviews and suspended reviews on the policy-violating profiles.
  • The Toronto Star (October 19, 2026) names the company and reports that the researcher linked it to bought Google reviews. The customer in the Star’s story says she was pleased with the work she received.

What the company says

  • The window company CTV contacted said it has never instructed, authorized or knowingly engaged anyone to post bought reviews or create bought listings on its behalf. company-stated
  • Its website presents it as a manufacturer and installer that makes its own products at its Vaughan facility. company-stated

What is not established

  • That the company paid for, requested or knew about the reviews. A pattern of suspicious reviews does not show who is behind it.
  • That the company’s windows or installation are poor. The Star’s customer reports a good experience.
  • Any finding by a court, regulator or Google about the company itself.

What customers say

Summaries in our words of reviews posted on n49. Names are removed. These reviews date from 2011 to 2016, so they come from before, and are separate from, the Google reviews the researcher analyzed. We have not verified them.

n49 shows 4.8 out of 5 from 14 reviews. Yelp shows 2.8 from 6 reviews, which we were not able to read.

Customer reviews

A bay window and a slider were installed in a living room renovation. The customer praises the service and says the quote was lower than other companies.

n49 review, July 2016. Source: n49 listing.

The customer bought everything and used the company’s installers, describing the installers as thorough and professional.

n49 review, June 2016. Source: n49 listing.

All windows and a patio door were replaced. The sales rep was knowledgeable and did not pressure the customer, and the installers were efficient and left the house tidy.

n49 review, December 2013. Source: n49 listing.

A customer says a front door installed earlier was faulty and took years to be replaced, and that the crew who finally replaced it were professional and tidy. They would recommend the company only with that crew.

n49 review, September 2015. Source: n49 listing.

The customer had doubts after the job was done. A window with a defect in the glass was replaced without argument, which the customer found unusual.

n49 review, March 2011. Source: n49 listing.

Critical reviews

We did not find detailed critical reviews of this company on the sites we could read. That does not mean none exist, so check the platforms directly.

Company snapshot

Location
Vaughan, Ontario
Operating since
2007, per TrustedPros
What it does
Manufactures and installs windows and doors
Ratings
TrustedPros 4.9 (4 reviews). n49 4.8 (14 reviews, 2011 to 2016). Yelp 2.8 (6 reviews).
Checked
Ratings change, so check the platforms directly.

Level A: court decision

Canadian Thermo Windows Inc. (Magic Windows)

Woodbridge, Ontario. Topic: pressure on customers over reviews. This case is not about bought reviews.

In 2021 an Ontario court dismissed a defamation lawsuit the company filed against customers over three negative reviews, found it was meant to pressure them into taking the reviews down, and ordered the company to pay $166,687.

What the court found

  • A couple bought 14 windows and a sliding door and reported leaks after installation. They wrote three negative online reviews.
  • The company asked them to delete the reviews. When they refused, it sued for defamation.
  • The couple brought a motion under Ontario’s anti-SLAPP law, which exists to stop lawsuits that silence public debate. Justice Fred Myers granted it and dismissed the suit.
  • The judge found the lawsuit was meant to pressure the couple into removing their reviews, and said customers discussing the quality of a company’s products is a matter of public interest.
  • The decision also notes that the company offered no expert evidence pointing to another cause of the leaks, and that there was evidence it had threatened lawsuits against other reviewers.
  • The company was ordered to pay $166,687 in costs and damages.

What the company says

  • Its lawyers told CTV News that the statements about the company were untrue. company-stated
  • They also said the ruling means the company lost its right to a trial and must pay the customers’ legal costs for having asserted it. company-stated

What is not established

  • That the company posts or buys bought reviews. The case does not address that.
  • How the company deals with reviews today. The ruling concerns one dispute in 2021.
  • Whether the customers’ windows were defective. The court decided the lawsuit’s purpose, not the product dispute.

What customers say

Summaries in our words of reviews posted on HomeStars. Names are removed. We have not verified them.

The company trades as Magic Windows. HomeStars shows 4.9 out of 5 from 804 reviews. The reviews below are a sample from 2015 and 2022.

Customer reviews

All windows in the home were replaced. The customer is happy with the product and workmanship, and the installers worked on a Saturday to finish in time. A service visit the following week adjusted the blinds.

HomeStars review, August 2022, 5 of 5. Source: HomeStars, Magic profile.

The customer chose a window wall partly because the company is Canadian and offers a 40-year warranty. They report good service since the 2019 installation.

HomeStars review, July 2022, 5 of 5. Source: HomeStars, Magic profile.

A problem with a custom patio door was fixed at no charge after customer service responded promptly.

HomeStars review, July 2022, 5 of 5. Source: HomeStars, Magic profile.

The customer is happy with the windows but says after-sales service was lacking: they waited more than a month to have a screen fixed, and an appointment was missed.

HomeStars review, August 2015, 5 of 5. Source: HomeStars, Magic profile.

Critical reviews

A couple who bought 14 windows and a sliding door reported leaking after installation and wrote three negative reviews. When they refused to delete them, the company sued them. The court dismissed the lawsuit. We were not able to retrieve the text of their reviews.

The company’s lawyers say the statements about the company were untrue.

Reported by CTV News Toronto, October 2021. Source: CTV News Toronto.

Company snapshot

Location
Woodbridge, Ontario
Trades as
Magic Windows, per CTV
Ratings
HomeStars: 4.9 from 804 reviews
Case
Canadian Thermo Windows Inc. v. Seangio, 2021 ONSC 6555, decided October 4, 2021

Bought review reports on record in Canada

Bought and manipulated reviews are documented by Canadian reporters and by the federal Competition Bureau. These are the reports we rely on for context.

  • January 2020CBC Marketplace

    An investigation into locksmiths found more than 80 Google Maps listings in the Greater Toronto Area with false information, along with bought five-star reviews. Read the CBC report.

  • 2021CBC News investigation

    CBC catalogued part of one bought-review network on Google: 208 bought accounts that posted 3,574 reviews for 1,279 businesses across North America. The work drew on research by Kay Dean, an independent researcher. Read the CBC investigation.

  • Competition BureauPenalty on FlightHub

    The Bureau fined the online travel agency FlightHub $5 million, and two of its directors $400,000, after the company published bought positive customer reviews. Read the news report.

  • December 2024AP / The Transparency Company

    A review-analysis company examined 73 million reviews in home, legal and medical services and judged nearly 14% likely to be bought. It said it was highly confident that about 2.3 million were partly or entirely written with AI tools. The report also notes that a review written with AI is not necessarily bought. Read the report coverage.

  • July 2026CTV News Toronto

    CTV reported on Google reviews for a Toronto window business that appeared under the names of famous actors who do not live in Canada. CTV did not name the business. Google said it removed the reviews and suspended reviews on the profiles involved. Read the CTV report.

  • October 2026Toronto Star

    The Star’s guide to spotting bought reviews cites a projection that bought reviews will cost online consumers US$1.07 trillion by 2030, and features a Vaughan window company that an independent researcher has linked to bought Google reviews. Read the Star article.

How to check a window company’s reviews yourself

You don’t need special tools. A few minutes on the review pages tells you more than the average score.

Reading the reviews

  • Open the reviewer profiles. Empty or locked profiles and accounts with a single review are weaker evidence than a profile with years of varied reviews.
  • Look at what else they review. The same names praising unrelated businesses in other cities or countries is a red flag.
  • Watch for bursts. A pile of five-star reviews in a few days, after a quiet stretch, deserves a second look.
  • Read for substance. Real customers mention measuring, scheduling, installers, clean-up and what happened when something went wrong.
  • Notice repeated phrasing. Similar sentences across different profiles suggest one author.
  • Be careful with “this sounds like AI.” Polished, generic praise is a reason to look closer. But nobody can reliably tell AI text from human text by reading it, and a review written with AI help is not automatically bought. Judge the profile, the timing and the details instead.
  • Compare platforms. Check Google, HomeStars, BBB and Trustpilot. A big gap between them is worth asking about.
  • Read the one-star reviews and the replies. How a company answers a complaint tells you more than its star average.

Before you sign

  • Get the warranty in writing, including who honours it, what it covers (glass breakage, labour, seals) and for how long.
  • Check the payment schedule. Ask what is paid at signing, at delivery and after installation, and whether a holdback applies.
  • Confirm who measures and who pulls permits. Many problems come from measurements and building-code requirements that nobody owned.
  • Ask for recent local addresses where you can see or ask about completed work.
  • Be wary of review deals. Money, discounts or warranty terms offered in exchange for removing or changing a review are a warning sign.
  • Keep records. Save the contract, quote, emails and photos of the install.

These are general consumer tips, not legal advice. If you think a review is bought, you can report it to the platform that hosts it.

Frequently asked questions about bought window and door reviews

Which window and door companies should I be careful with?

We can’t tell you which company to avoid, and nobody can judge a company from the outside. What we can do is show what has been reported, by whom, and how strong the evidence is. Our case files cover three companies, and each is graded Level A, B or C.

If you are considering Ecoline Windows and Doors, read the record before you sign. The BBB profile for its Calgary branch lists 29 complaints in the last three years, 4 of them in the last 12 months. They concern service and repair problems, customer service and order issues, including disagreements over contract terms. Ecoline replied to the complaints we read, generally saying it delivered what the contract covered. The same BBB profile shows an A+ rating and an average of 4.72 out of 5 from 118 customer reviews.

Separately, a few customers have said on TrustedPros and Reddit that they were offered money or pressured over negative reviews. Those claims are unconfirmed, and we found no evidence that Ecoline posts or buys bought reviews.

Our advice is the same for any company, Ecoline included. Read the contract (scope, warranty, payment schedule), check recent complaints and how the company replied, compare several platforms instead of trusting a star average, and use our checklist.

How can I tell if a review of a window company is bought?

No single sign proves it. Look for locked or empty reviewer profiles, many five-star reviews in a few days, generic praise that never mentions measuring or installation, repeated phrasing across profiles, and the same names reviewing unrelated businesses in other cities or countries. Compare Google with HomeStars, BBB and Trustpilot, and read the one-star reviews and the company’s replies.

Does a company with suspicious reviews sell bad windows?

Not necessarily. Suspicious reviews say something about how a company is presented online, not about its product. A customer quoted by the Toronto Star said she was pleased with her windows even after learning the company had been linked to bought Google reviews. Check contracts, warranties and installation details separately.

Are bought reviews illegal in Canada?

The Competition Bureau has warned that bought reviews, including undisclosed reviews written by employees, can lead to penalties under the Competition Act. It fined the online travel agency FlightHub $5 million, and two of its directors $400,000, after the company published bought positive customer reviews.

What do evidence levels A, B and C mean?

Level A is a court decision or a regulator’s finding. Level B is a claim by an independent researcher that news media have reported, which the company disputes and no court or regulator has ruled on. Level C is a claim made by customers on review sites or forums that nobody independent has confirmed.

What can I do if I am named here and disagree?

Tell us. We will check the statement, correct errors promptly, and publish your response alongside your company’s file. Please include the page, the statement in question, and any documents that support your correction.

Where can I report a suspected bought review?

Report it to the platform that hosts it, such as Google, HomeStars, BBB or Trustpilot, using the report option next to the review. Keep screenshots and the date you saw it.

How this review watch works

We are a window company writing about other window companies, so the rules below matter more than usual.

Our rules

  • No conflicts. We do not accept payment to add, remove or alter any company’s file.
  • Sources first. Every claim links to the original report, court decision or review page, and carries a date.
  • Attribution. We say who made each claim. We do not state as fact anything a source only alleges.
  • Both sides. Each case file includes the company’s response and what has not been established.
  • Customer voices. Reviews shown on this site are summaries in our own words of posts on third-party platforms. We remove names and identifying details, show praise and criticism, and note whether the company responded.
  • No guessing. We do not speculate about who is behind a review or why, and we do not publish personal details of reviewers.

Limits

  • Review scores and counts change daily. Figures show what we saw on the date shown on each file.
  • Reports by researchers, customers and the press are not court or regulatory findings unless a file says so (Level A).
  • A company’s absence from this site means nothing. We have not reviewed the whole industry.
  • Some sources were not available to us in full. Where we rely on a summary, we say so.

Corrections and right of reply

If you are a company named here, or you think something on this site is wrong, tell us. We will check it, correct errors promptly, and publish a company’s response alongside its file.

How to reach us: send your request through our contact page and mark your message “Corrections.”

Please include the page, the statement in question, and any documents that support your correction.